Where to Sell Pokemon Cards in New York

Get Cash for Your Pokemon Cards • Instant Market Prices • KYC-Verified Sellers

Serving 15 Cities Across NYLowest Fees: 6.9%100% Authenticated Trades

Sell Pokemon Cards for Cash in New York

Who Buys Pokemon Cards Near Me in New York?

Double Holo connects you with verified buyers across all 15 cities in New York who want your Pokemon cards. From New York City to Buffalo to Rochester, our marketplace features KYC-verified sellers who have completed identity verification through Stripe Connect, ensuring safe and legitimate transactions statewide.

Verified Sellers: All sellers in NY complete KYC/KYB verification via Stripe
High-Reputation Buyers: Choose buyers across New York based on reputation scores
Instant Market Prices: See real-time offers from buyers in New York
Fast Cash Payouts: Get paid directly to your bank account via Stripe Connect
6.9% Seller Fees: Keep 93.1% of your sale (vs 87% on eBay, 89.75% on TCGPlayer)

What Pokemon Cards Are Worth Money in New York?

Check real-time market prices instantly to find out what your Pokemon cards are worth. Our marketplace shows live pricing data updated daily from actual sales across New York and nationwide.

Most Valuable Pokemon Cards (2025):

• Charizard Base Set 1st Edition (PSA 10): $500K+
• Pikachu Illustrator: $5M+
• Charizard VMAX Rainbow Rare: $400+
• Umbreon VMAX Alternate Art: $300+
• Lugia Neo Genesis 1st Edition (PSA 10): $10K+
• Your cards might be valuable - check prices now!

Check Your Card Values Now →

How to Sell Pokemon Cards in New York (Complete Guide)

Selling your Pokemon cards on Double Holo is simple, secure, and profitable. Here's our step-by-step process for sellers across New York:

Create Free Account

Complete Seller Verification

Verify your identity through Stripe Connect (KYC). This protects buyers and ensures you get paid. Takes 5 minutes.

List Your Cards

Search for your card, see current market price, set your asking price. Add photos and condition details.

Get Paid

When your card sells, funds are transferred directly to your bank account. Keep 93.1% of the sale price.

Special Offer for New York Sellers

Join Double Holo today and get a $200 cash bonus when you sell your first 3 Pokemon cards and list 100 different cards! That's right - sell your first 3 Pokemon cards, list 100 different cards, and get a $200 cash bonus. After that, enjoy our industry-leading 6.9% fee forever. This offer is available to new sellers across all 15 cities in NY. View official terms & conditions →

Start Selling Today - Get Your $200 Cash Bonus →

How to Tell if Pokemon Cards Are Fake (Authentication Guide)

Worried about counterfeit cards in New York? Double Holo's middleman trade service provides professional authentication to protect both buyers and sellers from fake Pokemon cards across all 15 cities.

Double Holo's Anti-Fraud Protection

Middleman Escrow Service: High-value trades go through our middleman who authenticates cards before completing the transaction.
KYC-Verified Sellers: All sellers in NY complete identity verification through Stripe Connect, reducing fraud risk by 99%.
Buyer Protection: If you receive a fake card, you're protected. We issue full refunds for items determined to be counterfeit by our authentication service.
Zero-Tolerance Policy: Sellers who list fake cards are permanently banned and reported to authorities.

Signs of Fake Pokemon Cards

Wrong font or text spacing - Official cards use specific fonts
Incorrect colors or image quality - Fakes often have washed-out colors
Wrong card back - The Pokéball should be centered and crisp
Poor card stock quality - Real cards use specific thickness
Missing texture/holofoil - Authentic holos have distinct patterns
Spelling errors or wrong symbols - Dead giveaway of counterfeits
Price too good to be true - Scammers undercut market prices

Pro Tip for New York Collectors: For high-value cards ($500+), always use our middleman service. It costs just 2.5% of the trade value of your cards, and provides 100% authentication guarantee. Minimum $2.50 fee per trade.

Why New York Collectors Trust Double Holo for Authentication

Unlike Facebook Marketplace, Craigslist, or OfferUp, where anyone can list anything, Double Holo requires full identity verification through Stripe Connect. This means:

Bank-Level KYC

Same verification as banking apps

ID Verification

Government ID required

Seller Background Checks

Stripe vets all sellers

Major Pokemon Card Cities in New York

Double Holo serves Pokemon card collectors and sellers across New York's largest cities. Click any city below for location-specific information:

New York City, NY

Sell Pokemon cards for cash • Get instant offers

Serving New York County

8,398,748 residents

Buffalo, NY

Sell Pokemon cards for cash • Get instant offers

Serving Erie County

258,959 residents

Rochester, NY

Sell Pokemon cards for cash • Get instant offers

Serving Monroe County

210,358 residents

Yonkers, NY

Sell Pokemon cards for cash • Get instant offers

Serving Westchester County

199,766 residents

Syracuse, NY

Sell Pokemon cards for cash • Get instant offers

Serving Onondaga County

144,669 residents

Albany, NY

Sell Pokemon cards for cash • Get instant offers

Serving Albany County

98,469 residents

Pokemon Cards Available in New York

Popular Pokemon Singles

Charizard cards - Base Set, Shining, VMAX, ex
Pikachu cards - Original, Celebrations, Promos
Trainer cards - Professor Oak, Bill, Rare Candy
Energy cards - Special energies, secret rares
Full art cards - Trainers, Pokemon, supports
Rainbow rare cards - GX, VMAX, VSTAR
Gold cards - Secret rares, ultra rares
Japanese exclusive cards

Sealed Products & Graded Cards

Booster boxes - All sets available
Elite Trainer Boxes (ETBs)
Collection boxes - Premium collections
Theme decks & Battle decks
PSA graded cards - PSA 10, PSA 9, PSA 8
BGS graded cards - Black labels, pristine 10
CGC graded cards - Perfect 10, pristine
Vintage sealed products from 1999-2003

Why New York Collectors Choose Double Holo

Lowest Fees in the Industry

Only 6.9% seller fees compared to eBay (12.9%), TCGPlayer (10.25%), Mercari (10%), and other platforms. Keep more money from your Pokemon card sales across NY.

KYC-Verified Sellers Only

All sellers complete identity verification through Stripe Connect. This bank-level KYC/KYB process ensures you're trading with legitimate collectors in New York, not scammers.

Real-Time Market Pricing

Instantly see what your Pokemon cards are worth with our live market data. Updated daily from actual sales so you know the true value of your collection in New York.

Middleman Authentication Service

For high-value trades, our middleman service authenticates cards before completing the transaction. Protection against fake cards for New York buyers and sellers.

Statewide & Nationwide Reach

Serving all 15 cities across New York and collectors in all 50 states. Buy locally or access nationwide inventory.

Fast, Secure Payouts

Get paid directly to your bank account via Stripe. No waiting 30 days like other marketplaces. Funds available within 10 business days for New York sellers.

Frequently Asked Questions - New York Pokemon Card Sellers

Where can I sell Pokemon cards near me in New York?

You can sell Pokemon cards in New York on Double Holo's online marketplace, serving all 15 cities including New York City, Buffalo, and Rochester. Unlike local card shops that offer 30-50% of market value, Double Holo lets you sell directly to buyers at market prices with only 6.9% fees. You can choose to sell to only high-reputation buyers, or to all buyers.

Who buys Pokemon cards in New York?

Double Holo connects you with thousands of verified Pokemon card buyers across New York and nationwide. You can choose to sell to only high-reputation buyers, ensuring legitimate transactions. You can sell individual cards or entire collections from anywhere in NY.

How do I sell Pokemon cards for cash in New York?

To sell Pokemon cards for cash in New York: (1) Create a free Double Holo account, (2) Complete Stripe seller verification (5 minutes), (3) List your cards with photos, (4) When cards sell, cash is deposited directly to your bank account within 10 business days. You keep 93.1% of the sale price.

What Pokemon cards are worth money in New York?

Valuable Pokemon cards include: 1st Edition Base Set Charizard ($500K+), Pikachu Illustrator ($5M+), modern chase cards like Umbreon VMAX Alt Art ($300+), PSA 10 vintage holos, and sealed vintage products. Use Double Holo's marketplace to check current market prices for your specific cards in New York.

How can I tell if my Pokemon cards are fake?

Signs of fake Pokemon cards include: wrong font/text spacing, incorrect colors, poor card stock quality, missing texture on holofoils, spelling errors, and prices too good to be true. On Double Holo, all sellers are KYC-verified, and our middleman service authenticates high-value cards before completing trades in New York.

Are Pokemon card sellers verified on Double Holo in New York?

Yes! All sellers on Double Holo, including those in NY, must complete KYC (Know Your Customer) and KYB (Know Your Business) verification through Stripe Connect. This is the same bank-level identity verification used by financial institutions, making Double Holo the safest place to buy Pokemon cards in New York.

What are Double Holo's seller fees in New York?

Double Holo charges just 6.9% seller fees - the lowest in the industry. Compare this to eBay (12.9%), TCGPlayer (10.25%), and Mercari (10%). For a $100 card sale in New York, you keep $93.10 on Double Holo vs $87.10 on eBay - that's $6 more per sale. Plus, we currently offer a $200 cash bonus to new sellers who sell their first 3 Pokemon cards and list 100 different cards!