Is Beckett (BGS) as Good as PSA? Prices, Subgrades and Black Label

What BGS 9.5, Pristine 10 and Black Label slabs sell for against PSA 10 on the same Pokemon cards, and when each company makes sense.

Grading

It depends on the grade. In Double Holo's data, a BGS 9.5 sold for a median 68% of the PSA 10 price across 13 popular modern cards (as of November 19, 2026). A BGS 10 Pristine sold for a median 1.7 times the PSA 10 price (12 modern cards) and a Black Label for 12 times the PSA 10 price (5 cards).

Double Holo graded market prices, based on recent sales of each exact grade.

Updated November 19, 2026 · refreshed daily

Most answers to "is BGS as good as PSA?" come from sports cards. This one uses Pokemon card sales: Double Holo's graded prices for the same cards in PSA 10, BGS 9.5, BGS 10 Pristine, and the BGS Black Label. The short version is that Beckett (BGS) and PSA price very differently depending on the grade.

The short answer

A common rule of thumb says a BGS 9.5 is roughly equal to a PSA 10. On Pokemon cards, Double Holo's market data does not back that up: the BGS 9.5 sold below the PSA 10 on all 13 modern cards.

  • Gem Mint is a different number: Beckett's Gem Mint grade is a 9.5, while PSA's Gem Mint grade is a 10, PSA's top grade.
  • Beckett's scale: Beckett (BGS) grades on a 1 to 10 scale in half points, including 9.5, and can add four subgrades to the label: centering, corners, edges and surface. Subgrades are an option you choose when you submit.
  • PSA's scale: PSA gives one overall grade with no subgrades, and its scale has no 9.5 step, so a card goes from PSA 9 straight to PSA 10.

What the price data shows

In Double Holo's data, a BGS 9.5 sold for a median 68% of the PSA 10 price across 13 popular modern cards (as of November 19, 2026). A BGS 10 Pristine sold for a median 1.7 times the PSA 10 price (12 modern cards) and a Black Label for 12 times the PSA 10 price (5 cards). A median is the typical (middle) result: half the cards sit above it and half below. Modern here means Sword & Shield and Scarlet & Violet.

Example modern cards with their PSA 10, BGS 9.5, BGS 10 Pristine, and BGS 10 Black Label prices and sale counts, and the BGS 9.5 price as a share of the PSA 10 price
CardPSA 10BGS 9.5BGS 10 PristineBGS 10 Black LabelBGS 9.5 as % of PSA 10
Umbreon VMAX
Evolving Skies 215/203
$3,385
based on 5 sales
$2,400
based on 5 sales
$6,018
based on 5 sales
$24,389
based on 5 sales
71%
Charizard ex
Obsidian Flames 223/197
$573
based on 5 sales
$391
based on 5 sales
No recent salesNo recent sales68%
Pikachu ex
Surging Sparks 238/191
$693
based on 5 sales
$475
based on 5 sales
$1,326
based on 5 sales
No recent sales69%
Charizard ex
Scarlet & Violet 151 199/165
$1,138
based on 5 sales
$490
based on 5 sales
$7,500
based on 5 sales
No recent sales43%
Giratina V
Lost Origin 186/196
$2,966
based on 5 sales
$2,024
based on 5 sales
$3,485
based on 5 sales
No recent sales68%
Umbreon ex
Prismatic Evolutions 161/131
$4,108
based on 5 sales
$2,487
based on 5 sales
$6,869
based on 5 sales
$44,564
based on 3 sales
61%

Prices are in US dollars. Each price is Double Holo's market price for that exact grade, built from recent sales of copies in that grade. A card counts only when the PSA 10 and the BGS grade are both backed by at least 3 sales and the newest of them is within the last 120 days (older sales can still feed the price). 13 of the 16 modern cards qualified for the BGS 9.5 comparison as of November 19, 2026; the table shows a selection. These are well-known cards Double Holo picked, so the gap on other cards can differ. BGS 10 and Black Label figures cover modern cards only; check vintage cards on their own pages. Prices move daily, and a median across cards is a pattern, not a quote for any one card.

Double Holo Premium
Stop overpaying for Pokemon cards. Stop losing money grading cards.
AI Picks, sentiment, grading ROI, and price forecasts, refreshed daily. Free for 3 days on any annual plan.
Start your 3-day free trial

BGS 9.5, Pristine 10, and Black Label

Beckett uses label color to mark its top grades: gold for Gem Mint 9.5 and Pristine 10, black for a Pristine 10 with all four subgrades at 10 (the Black Label), and silver for the rest.

A BGS 9.5 is Beckett's Gem Mint grade, the one most BGS slabs at the top of the scale carry. A BGS 10 Pristine is an overall 10. A Black Label is a Pristine 10 where all four subgrades are also 10, which makes it the hardest BGS grade to get. Double Holo prices the Black Label separately from other BGS 10s.

What subgrades add

When you choose subgrades, the label shows four scores next to the overall grade: centering, corners, edges, and surface. That tells a buyer where the card lost points, which a single PSA number does not. The overall grade is not a simple average of the four, so read each subgrade, not just the number on top. A BGS 9.5 with three 10 subgrades is a different card from a BGS 9.5 with a 9 in one category, and buyers can see the difference.

PSA vs BGS at a glance

PSA and BGS compared on scale, top grades, subgrades, labels, and price on Double Holo
FeaturePSABGS (Beckett)
Gem Mint grade109.5
Grades above Gem MintNonePristine 10, and the Black Label (a Pristine 10 with all four subgrades at 10)
9.5 stepNo, PSA 9 goes straight to PSA 10Yes
SubgradesNoOptional: centering, corners, edges, surface
Price against a PSA 10 on Double Holo (modern medians, as of November 19, 2026)PSA 10 is the baselineBGS 9.5: 68% of the PSA 10 price (13 cards)
BGS 10 Pristine: 1.7 times the PSA 10 price (12 cards)
Black Label: 12 times the PSA 10 price (5 cards)

Which grade sells more often

Of the 16 modern cards Double Holo checked, 16 had enough recent PSA 10 sales to price, 13 had enough BGS 9.5 sales, 12 had enough BGS 10 Pristine sales, and 5 had enough Black Label sales (as of November 19, 2026). A card counts when its grade had at least 3 sales with the newest in the last 120 days, so this is a rough measure of which grades trade steadily, not a count of every sale.

Choose PSA or BGS

Choose PSA if

  • Your card is clean but probably not flawless. On modern cards a PSA 10 sold above a BGS 9.5 on all 13 cards, so a likely 10 usually earns more at PSA.
  • You want one simple grade that the most buyers recognize.
  • You do not need subgrades on the label.

Choose BGS if

  • Your card is close to perfect and has a real shot at a Pristine 10 or a Black Label. On modern cards a BGS 10 Pristine sold for a median 1.7 times the PSA 10 price.
  • You want subgrades on the label to show buyers exactly where the card is strong.
  • You want a grade that can show a card is better than a 9 but short of a 10, which PSA's scale cannot.

What is different for Pokemon cards

Every number on this page comes from Pokemon card sales, not sports cards. On the modern Pokemon cards Double Holo checked, a BGS 9.5 sells below a PSA 10, while a BGS 10 Pristine sells above it. The BGS 10 and Black Label figures on this page cover modern cards only, so for vintage cards, check each card's own page.

Who owns Beckett?

In December 2025, Collectors, the parent company of PSA, announced an agreement to buy Beckett, and said Beckett would keep running as its own brand and keep doing its own grading. For collectors, the two still grade separately, so a BGS slab and a PSA slab of the same card are still priced separately.

Check your own card

The gap changes from card to card, so look up yours. Every card page on Double Holo shows recent prices for each grade, for example Umbreon VMAX (Evolving Skies 215/203), Charizard ex (Obsidian Flames 223/197), and Pikachu ex (Surging Sparks 238/191). To find a card fast, use the Pokemon card value checker. Deciding whether a raw card is worth sending in at all? Double Holo Premium's Grading ROI tool lines up raw and graded values for you.

Frequently asked questions

Is Beckett (BGS) as good as PSA?

It depends on the grade. In Double Holo's data, a BGS 9.5 sold for a median 68% of the PSA 10 price across 13 popular modern cards (as of November 19, 2026). A BGS 10 Pristine sold for a median 1.7 times the PSA 10 price (12 modern cards) and a Black Label for 12 times the PSA 10 price (5 cards). A common rule of thumb says a BGS 9.5 is roughly equal to a PSA 10. On Pokemon cards, Double Holo's market data does not back that up: the BGS 9.5 sold below the PSA 10 on all 13 modern cards. The better slab for you depends on the grade you expect your card to get.

Is a BGS 9.5 equal to a PSA 10?

Not on price. Beckett's Gem Mint grade is a 9.5, while PSA's Gem Mint grade is a 10, PSA's top grade. In Double Holo's data, a BGS 9.5 sold for a median 68% of the PSA 10 price across 13 popular modern cards (as of November 19, 2026). No official conversion exists between the two companies.

Is a BGS Black Label worth more than a PSA 10?

On the cards where it trades, yes. In Double Holo's market data, a BGS 10 Black Label sold for a median 12 times the PSA 10 price across 5 modern cards with enough recent sales (as of November 19, 2026). Black Labels are rare, so few cards have enough sales to price, and the gap varies a lot from card to card.

What are BGS subgrades?

Beckett (BGS) grades on a 1 to 10 scale in half points, including 9.5, and can add four subgrades to the label: centering, corners, edges and surface. Subgrades are an option you choose when you submit. The overall grade is not a simple average of the four, so check each subgrade, not just the number on top. Beckett uses label color to mark its top grades: gold for Gem Mint 9.5 and Pristine 10, black for a Pristine 10 with all four subgrades at 10 (the Black Label), and silver for the rest.

Does PSA own Beckett?

In December 2025, Collectors, the parent company of PSA, announced an agreement to buy Beckett, and said Beckett would keep running as its own brand and keep doing its own grading. PSA and Beckett still grade separately, so a BGS slab and a PSA slab are priced separately.

Related reading

Is a CGC 10 Equal to a PSA 10? - CGC 10 and Pristine 10 prices against PSA 10.

PSA vs CGC vs BGS - how the three big grading companies compare, and how to pick one for your card.

Sources
Pokemon GradingPSABGSBeckettGraded CardsMarket Data
Hot card dealsAll deals

Running a card show table or a TCG storefront? Double Holo also builds card show POS, free to start with 50 active items and plans from $14.17/mo billed annually (the Founding Vendor price for your first 12 months when you subscribe on the web, regularly $16.67/mo): live inventory, automated repricing, and price label printing, connected to a marketplace of 196,709 collectors.