Is a PSA 5 a good grade?

A PSA 5 (Excellent) is a budget grade for vintage Pokemon cards: in Double Holo's market data it sold for a median 62% of the raw near mint price on vintage cards (as of November 2026).

Double Holo graded prices from recent sales of each exact grade; raw prices are the daily near mint market price.

Updated November 19, 2026 · refreshed daily

On vintage cards, a PSA 5 sold for a median 62% of the raw near mint price (11 cards), 79% of the PSA 6 price (14 cards), and 1% of the PSA 10 price (9 cards). On 11 of those 11 vintage cards, the PSA 5 sold for less than the raw near mint price. Only 3 of the 21 modern cards Double Holo tracked for this guide had enough recent PSA 5 sales, too few to state a median.

What a PSA 5 means

PSA 5 is PSA's Excellent grade, printed as EX 5 on the label. PSA's standard describes an Excellent 5 as a card where wear starts to show: the corners begin to round and surface wear or printing defects are easier to see.

Flaws PSA allows at this grade

  • Very minor rounding of the corners
  • Minor chipping on the edges
  • Several light scratches on close inspection
  • More loss of the original gloss

PSA also sets a centering limit for each grade, front and back. See PSA's grading standards for the exact figures.

PSA 5 prices on popular cards

PSA 5 prices next to raw near mint and nearby PSA grades
CardRaw near mint (daily market price)PSA 4PSA 5PSA 6PSA 10
Charizard (Base Set 4/102)$1,001-$413 (5 sales)$522 (5 sales)$38,828 (5 sales)
Blastoise (Base Set 2/102)$234-$114 (5 sales)$143 (5 sales)$12,080 (5 sales)
Dark Charizard (Team Rocket 4/82)$384-$232 (5 sales)$249 (5 sales)$13,962 (4 sales)
Lugia (Neo Genesis 9/111)$513-$438 (5 sales)$555 (5 sales)-
Umbreon VMAX (Evolving Skies 215/203)$2,211-$1,563 (5 sales)$1,800 (5 sales)$3,385 (5 sales)
Giratina V (Lost Origin 186/196)$821-$509 (3 sales)-$2,966 (5 sales)

Source: Double Holo market data - as of November 19, 2026

A dash means fewer than three recent sales in that grade, or no recent near mint raw sale.

When a PSA 5 is a good buy, and when it is not

A good buy when

  • You want a graded vintage copy for about the price of a raw one or less. A vintage PSA 5 sold for a median 62% of the raw near mint price.
  • You want the card in a slab for less than the next grade. A PSA 5 cost a median 79% of a PSA 6 on vintage cards.

Not a good buy when

  • You expect the slab to be worth more than a raw card. On 11 of 11 vintage cards a PSA 5 sold for less than a raw near mint copy.
  • You are buying mainly to resell for a profit. A PSA 5 sold for a median 1% of a PSA 10 on vintage cards, so most of a card's graded value sits in the top grades.

Deciding whether to send in a card of your own? The grading ROI calculator compares a card's raw value with what each grade sells for, after fees.

Frequently asked questions

Is a PSA 5 good?

A PSA 5 (Excellent) is a budget grade for vintage Pokemon cards: in Double Holo's market data it sold for a median 62% of the raw near mint price on vintage cards (as of November 2026). On vintage cards, a PSA 5 sold for a median 62% of the raw near mint price (11 cards), 79% of the PSA 6 price (14 cards), and 1% of the PSA 10 price (9 cards). On 11 of those 11 vintage cards, the PSA 5 sold for less than the raw near mint price.

What does a PSA 5 card look like?

PSA's standard describes an Excellent 5 as a card where wear starts to show: the corners begin to round and surface wear or printing defects are easier to see. The flaws PSA's standard allows at this grade include: very minor rounding of the corners; minor chipping on the edges; several light scratches on close inspection; more loss of the original gloss.

How much cheaper is a PSA 5 than a PSA 10?

In Double Holo's market data, on 9 vintage cards a PSA 5 sold for a median 1% of the PSA 10 price (as of November 19, 2026).

Methodology

Prices are in US dollars. Each graded price is Double Holo's market price for that exact PSA grade, built from recent sales of copies in that grade. A graded price counts only when at least 3 sales back it and the newest is within the last 120 days. Raw prices are the daily near mint market price from an outside price feed, not Double Holo sales, and count only when the feed confirmed them in the last two days and a near mint copy sold in the last 30 days. A median is shown only when at least 8 cards in that era qualify. Prices for 45 of the 45 cards loaded as of November 19, 2026. Vintage means Wizards of the Coast era sets (1999 to 2002) and modern means Sword & Shield and Scarlet & Violet sets (2020 on). These are 45 well-known cards Double Holo picked, so other cards can differ, and prices move daily.